Building your own comms and choosing between them
Lesson overview
- Build a commutator for a case from an insertion and an interchange
- Fix a comm that cycles the wrong way
- Choose between two comms for the same case
Builds on: 3-style edges
Before you start
- A commutator [A, B] cycles three pieces when A and B share exactly one slot.
- A conjugate [S: [A, B]] sets pieces up for a commutator first.
The site gives you a verified comm for every case, but many solvers end up preferring their own. Building a comm is a short routine, and once you can do it no case is a mystery.
The routine
For the buffer and two targets:
- Find an interchange. Look for a layer, a face or a slice, that holds two of the three pieces. A single turn of it is the interchange.
- Find an insertion. The third piece is outside that layer. Look for a short sequence, often three moves, that takes it into the layer and back out, touching only one of the layer's slots.
- Put them together as [insertion, interchange] or [interchange, insertion].
- Check the direction. If the pieces cycle the wrong way round, swap the two parts: [B, A] is the reverse of [A, B].
- No interchange or insertion fits? Add a setup that moves one piece so they do, and write the whole thing as [setup: [A, B]].
Here's a comm built that way, part by part. The interchange is a slice turn:
And the same parts swapped, which cycles the same three edges the other way:
Checking your work
The commutator sandbox in Practice takes any comm you type, expands it, counts its moves and tells you exactly which pieces it moves. It only calls something a 3-cycle when the engine has checked it. Use it for every comm you build.
Choosing between comms
When a case has more than one comm, prefer:
- fewer moves after cancellation, since moves at the joins often cancel;
- no regrips, so your hands stay in one position throughout;
- moves you're fast at, even if the count is one higher;
- a shape you already know from a neighbouring case, since it's easier to recall.
In the 3-style trainer you can save your own comm for any case. It's checked before it's saved, and yours is shown first from then on.