Skip to content
Back to lessons

23. · 8 min

Building your own comms and choosing between them

Lesson overview
  • Build a commutator for a case from an insertion and an interchange
  • Fix a comm that cycles the wrong way
  • Choose between two comms for the same case

Builds on: 3-style edges

Before you start
  • A commutator [A, B] cycles three pieces when A and B share exactly one slot.
  • A conjugate [S: [A, B]] sets pieces up for a commutator first.

The site gives you a verified comm for every case, but many solvers end up preferring their own. Building a comm is a short routine, and once you can do it no case is a mystery.

The routine

For the buffer and two targets:

  1. Find an interchange. Look for a layer, a face or a slice, that holds two of the three pieces. A single turn of it is the interchange.
  2. Find an insertion. The third piece is outside that layer. Look for a short sequence, often three moves, that takes it into the layer and back out, touching only one of the layer's slots.
  3. Put them together as [insertion, interchange] or [interchange, insertion].
  4. Check the direction. If the pieces cycle the wrong way round, swap the two parts: [B, A] is the reverse of [A, B].
  5. No interchange or insertion fits? Add a setup that moves one piece so they do, and write the whole thing as [setup: [A, B]].

Here's a comm built that way, part by part. The interchange is a slice turn:

Loading the cube…

And the same parts swapped, which cycles the same three edges the other way:

Loading the cube…

Checking your work

The commutator sandbox in Practice takes any comm you type, expands it, counts its moves and tells you exactly which pieces it moves. It only calls something a 3-cycle when the engine has checked it. Use it for every comm you build.

Choosing between comms

When a case has more than one comm, prefer:

  • fewer moves after cancellation, since moves at the joins often cancel;
  • no regrips, so your hands stay in one position throughout;
  • moves you're fast at, even if the count is one higher;
  • a shape you already know from a neighbouring case, since it's easier to recall.

In the 3-style trainer you can save your own comm for any case. It's checked before it's saved, and yours is shown first from then on.

Checkpoint: Build a comm

Loading the cube…

How should lessons talk to you?

Pick a voice. The facts are the same in every one, and you can switch any time from the lesson header or Settings.

A local-only cubing workbench.Small steps. Deeper understanding.Contact · Privacy