Commutators: the [A, B] shape
Lesson overview
- Read and write out a commutator [A, B] and a conjugate [S: X]
- Name the insertion and the interchange in a commutator
- Say why a commutator moves only three pieces
Builds on: Your first full solve
Before you start
- Old Pochmann solves one target per alg; its swap moves extra pieces that cancel in pairs.
- Undoing a sequence means its moves in reverse order, each turned the other way.
Old Pochmann and M2 solve one target at a time. A commutator solves two at once: it moves three pieces round a cycle, the buffer and two targets, and leaves every other piece where it was. That's the whole of 3-style.
The notation
A commutator is written [A, B], where A and B are short move sequences. It means:
- do A;
- do B;
- undo A;
- undo B.
So [R, U] is R U R' U'. Nothing more to it.
A conjugate is written [S: X] and means S, then X, then undo S. It's how you set pieces up so that a commutator can reach them, exactly the way Old Pochmann's setups work.
Watch one, part by part
Step through this commutator. The three pieces it cycles are lit the whole time; watch everything else come back.
After A and B, the cube looks badly scrambled. Undoing A puts most of it back, and undoing B finishes the job, except for three pieces.
Insertion and interchange
The two parts of a commutator like this have jobs:
- The interchange is a single turn of a layer that holds two of the three pieces. Here it's B.
- The insertion is a short sequence that takes the third piece into that layer and back out, touching only one slot of the layer. Here it's L F' L'.
Which one goes first decides which way round the three pieces cycle. Swapping them, [L F' L', B], cycles the same three pieces the other way.
Why only three pieces move
A and B each move plenty of pieces, and the undos put almost all of them back. Trouble can only happen where A and B overlap. When they share exactly one slot, as an insertion and an interchange do, what's left over is always a cycle of exactly three pieces.
With a setup
Most useful comms need a setup first, written as a conjugate. Here the setup R' puts the pieces where an insertion and an interchange can reach them: